| 1998 |
|
| Kyle Kisinger |
Bethel, Morton, IL |
| Brian Wojcik |
St. John's, Lombard, IL |
| Billy Elmore |
Trinity, Bloomington, IL |
| Kevin Bischoff |
St. Peter, Milwaukee, WI |
| Mike Sieg |
Trinity, Bloomington, IL |
|
|
| 1997 |
|
| Tyson Siebers |
Bethany, Appleton, WI |
| Kyle Kisinger |
Bethel, Morton, IL |
| Steven Walker |
Grace, Menomenee Falls, WI |
| Brian Wojckik |
St. John, Lombard, IL |
| Eric Warwick |
Trinity English, Fort Wayne, IN |
| Kevin Jessen |
Trinity, Roselle, IL |
|
|
| 1990 |
|
| Ed Donahue |
St. Peter, East Peoria, IL |
| Matt Miller |
Christ Memorial, St. Louis, MO |
| Mike Radtke |
Good Shepherd, Appleton, WI |
| John Telger |
Bethel, Morton, IL |
| Andy Berg |
Our Redeemer, Wauwatosa, WI |
|
|
| 1989 |
|
| Jeff Woldt |
St. Paul, Grafton, WI |
| Rich Lanier |
Pilgrim, Decatur, IL |
| Jeff Willer |
Our Redeemer, Wauwatosa, WI |
| Steve Zucker |
St. Lorenz, Frankenmuth, MI |
| Jeff Mierow |
St. Paul, Grafton, WI |