| Year | Name | School | City, State |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2009 | Javonti George | St. Peter | Brooklyn, NY |
| 2008 | Gary Stone | St. Peter | Brooklyn, NY |
| 2007 | Brenden Schulz | St. John | Wauwatosa, WI |
| 2006 | Dennis McGrew | St. Stephens | Chicago, IL |
| 2005 | Cordaryll Ward | St. Stephens | Chicago, IL |
| 2004 | Wes Wilcox | Trinity | Chicago, IL |
| 2003 | Freddie Dilworth | St. Stephens | Chicago, IL |
| 2002 | Skyler Zarndt | St. Paul | Decatur, IL |
| 2001 | Carlton Brown | St. Stephens | Chicago, IL |
| 2000 | Jacob Summers | Christ | Peoria, IL |
| 1999 | Patrick Manore | Trinity English | Ft. Wayne, IN |
| 1998 | Mike Sieg | Trinity | Bloomington, IL |
| 1997 | Kevin Bischoff | St. Peter | Milwaukee, WI |
| 1996 | David Durkee | St. Paul | Decatur, IL |
| 1995 | Graham Conrad | Bethany Appleton | Appleton, WI |
| 1994 | George Rose | Trinity | Danville, iL |
| 1993 | Andy Sheets | Trinity | Bloomington, IL |
| 1992 | Scott Schauer | St. Peter - Immanuel | Milwaukee, WI |
| 1991 | James Popp | Holy Cross | Saginaw, MI |
| 1990 | Mike Radtke | Good Shepherd | Appleton, WI |
| 1989 | Jeremy Frank | St. Lorenz | Frankenmuth, MI |
| 1988 | Steve Lasch | Trinity | Bloomington, IL |
| 1987 | Kriss Kraussel | Covenant - Beautiful Savior | Milwaukee, WI |
| 1986 | Bret Montgomery | Good Shepherd | Saginaw, MI |